# A new response from the Federal Tax Service of the Russian Federation and a small explanation to this answer. A diary note

Владимир Владимирович Залесский

MMMDXLVI. A new response from the Federal Tax Service of the Russian Federation and a small explanation to this answer. A diary note. - September 27, 2024.

A new response from the Federal Tax Service of the Russian Federation and a small explanation to this answer. A diary note.


Today, September 27, 2024, I found an email in my email-box:


*@495 КБ09:52

ФНС РоссииБС-2-21/13634@ от 26.09.2024( о рассмотрении обращения Залесского В.В. ) Ответ на Ваше обращение находится в прикрепленном файле. Внимание. Не направляйте сообщений на адрес отправки данного письма - любые сообщения на этот адрес будут без рассмотрения автоматически удалены. Для


[*@495 КБ09:52

The Federal Tax Service of RussiaБС-2-21/13634@ dated September 26, 2024 (on consideration of the appeal of Zalessky V.V. ) The answer to your appeal is in the attached file. Attention. Do not send messages to the sending address of this letter - any messages to this address will be automatically deleted without consideration. For ]


Opening the attachment to this letter, I read a rather detailed and expertly written document: БС-2-21/13634@ dated September 26, 2024.


I must say right away that the question is: "why is the object of real estate not in the tax register?" I'm leaving this question aside.


Does such a situation violate the tax interests of the state or does it not? My age and the need for me to take care of my health encourage (direct) me to pay less attention to this topic.


But this letter contains information that may get a little clarification (from my side):


"According to the Administration of Federal Tax Service of Russia for the Rostov oblast (the letter dated September 24, 2024 No. 23-11/024451), according to an extract from the Unified State Register of Real Estate dated September 4, 2024, the real estate object indicated in the appeal belonged to you on the right of shared ownership from August 3, 2016 to June 3, 2019."


Yes, the real estate object belonged to me before June 3, 2019.


But, according to the certificate I received through the Multifunctional center for the provision of public services in 2024, I was not prosecuted (I was not criminally liable). How could I lose my right of ownership of the real estate object? This does not comply with the Constitution of the Russian Federation!!!


The response mentions the "right of shared ownership" according to an extract from the Unified State Register of Real Estate dated September 4, 2024.


The real estate object is a private house (house for two owners) with two independent entrances. Naturally, each owner owns independent premises.


My mother purchased this real estate object in 2006. (1) the contract of sale and (2) the statement of co-owners (both documents were notarized) were submitted to the state registration authority. In these documents, the premises that are being acquired (become the property of) the buyer, that is, my mother, were listed in the clearest way. The co-owners knew perfectly well what belonged to whom, and there were no ambiguities or objections on this issue.


All these documents ((1) the contract of sale and (2) the statement of co-owners) were transmitted into the notary office and into the state registration authority.


Around 2012, a noisy and wide-ranging campaign in the central media began, which explaining the advantages of not inheriting, but donating a real estate object.


Accordingly, at the end of 2012, my mother presented (donated) the object of real estate to me. Naturally, the donation agreement listed in the clearest way those premises that become the property of the donee (that is, of me).


In the responses from Rosreestr (which I received from Rosreestr), information about the premises belonging to me was duplicated, that is, information about the list and area of premises is well known. Calculating the amount of compensation according to state standards (rates) is not difficult.


If I lost my right of ownership on June 3, 2019 (despite the fact that according to the certificate I was not criminally liable) (I learned about the loss of my ownership right from the tax notice received by me in 2021), - then now I have the right to compensation.


To be absolutely precise, I learned about the loss of my ownership right from the responses to my statements. Having personally received (in my hands) a tax notice in the second half of 2021 and not finding a record (a mention) of the relevant real estate object in it, I began to apply - first to the Tax Inspectorate, which issued me the tax notice (my statement, dated October 01, 2021, to the Interdistrict Tax Inspectorate number 23 in the Rostov oblast) and then to other bodies. The answers to my statements informed me: it turns out, I was deprived of my property right back on June 3, 2019!!!


I could lose ownership right only after making changes to the Unified State Register of Real Estate by an official acting on behalf of the Russian Federation.


Thus, it is the Russian Federation that is obliged to pay me legitimate and fair compensation (taking into account the total area of the premises and current compensation standards (rates) for real estate objects seized by the state).


As far as I know, the issue of compensation is not within the competence of the Federal Tax Service of the Russian Federation. Therefore, I sent the statement to the Government of the Russian Federation (MCMXII. Application to the Government of the Russian Federation sent by e-mail. A diary note. - On April 27, 2022.).


September 27, 2024, 18:36


Translation from Russian into English: September 27, 2024 21:15

Владимир Владимирович Залесский ' Новый ответ из ФНС РФ и небольшое разъяснение к этому ответу. Дневниковая заметка '.


{ 3575. Новый ответ из ФНС РФ и небольшое разъяснение к этому ответу. Дневниковая заметка. - 27 сентября 2024 г.

MMMDXLVI. A new response from the Federal Tax Service of the Russian Federation and a small explanation to this answer. A diary note. - September 27, 2024.


Vladimir Zalessky Internet-bibliotheca. Интернет-библиотека Владимира Залесского. }