Аннотация: Towards the Moon. A compensation for the termination of my property rights by the state. A diary note.
Towards the Moon. A compensation for the termination of my property rights by the state. A diary note.
While reflecting on the text of my appeal to the Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation (in order to encourage the Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation to send a memo or other document to the Government of the Russian Federation on protecting the state's tax interests), I again read the answers that I received from the tax authorities.
One of the answers (dated December 23, 2021, number 23-16 / 3267@) contains the following words: "There are no grounds for calculating the tax on property of individuals for 2020 year in relation to the above property, due to the fact that your ownership terminated on June 3, 2019".
This is an interesting phrase. This means that my ownership right in the period up to June 3, 2019 is a fact.
The new owner of the property, as I guess, did not appear. (1) If such a new owner appeared, then I would be informed in some form, in favour that I would not worry about paying the tax. (2) The land plot continues to be registered with me.
How to call the "simple" "termination" of property rights?
For legal science and practice, this is probably something new, unknown, not named.
In this case, there are probably grounds to talk about causing me losses.
In what amount (volume)? Once I was interested in the average price per square meter in Rostov-on-Don. I multiplied the average market price per square meter (citywide) by the number of square meters in the property object and converted to US dollars at the current rate. It turned out approximately 80,000 (eighty thousand) US dollars. 80,000 dollars - this is at the approximate (approximate) today's rate (72 rubles for 1 US dollar) it turns out:
80000 times 72 equals 5,760,000 (five million seven hundred sixty thousand rubles).
In addition, in a market economy, every capital, every property brings some income. Which? This is a debatable area of reasoning. Usually they take the discount rate of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation as a basis. But this rate varies from period to period, so we may to take 5 percent per annum for simplicity.
5 percent of 5,760,000 rubles is equal to 288,000 (two hundred and eighty eight thousand) rubles. This is for a year.
But almost two and a half years have passed since June 3, 2019. For two and a half years - 288,000 times 2.5 is equal to 720,000 (seven hundred and twenty thousand) rubles.
You can go not from the market value, but from the "tax base" ("tax base" was indicated in my tax notice).
When I calculated (to help the tax authorities) the amount of underpaid tax, I took as a basis 6,633,913 (six million six hundred and thirty three thousand nine hundred and thirteen) rubles. My share "in the right" is half [the share in the rights on object is half]. 6633913 divided by 2, we get 3316957 (three million three hundred sixteen thousand nine hundred fifty seven) rubles.
Of course, 3316957 rubles is a clearly underestimated price. Why, if there is a higher market price per square meter in Rostov-on-Don, should I lose in a value? If prices have fallen, then this is another matter (then I will not argue). But recently the Deputy Prime Minister spoke and said that prices per square meter have risen - almost by 15 percent ...
That is, I am for justice. In a certain sense, this object is an inheritance I received (through a deed of gift).
If the state has carried out the alienation of my property, then I, as a peace-loving person, am inclined not to participate in the struggle for the property, but to receive compensation at average market prices plus lost profits (5 percent per annum for about 2.5 years period).
As for taxes, I do not refuse to pay them. When the situation is cleared up, I am ready to pay all underpaid taxes and thereby help the Russial Lunar Program.
The question is, should I raise the issue of compensation now in my appeal to the Ministry of Finance?
On the one hand, I applied (earlier) to the Ministry of Finance only on the issue of protecting the tax interests of the state.
On the other hand, it is the Ministry of Finance that is in charge of paying various kinds of compensation. To save time, maybe immediately raise the question of paying me compensation?
There is also a "third side". The leaders of our state constantly emphasize the concern for ordinary citizens. Many receive gifts, money transfers. Many people enjoy benefits of various kinds and for various reasons (grounds).
I don't get anything of this kind from the state. I do not claim to receive anything like this from the state.
I just want to be compensated for my property at fair prices - so as not to participate in the struggle and disputes ... (It turns out that I act as an "active citizen", challenging the correctness of the actions of state bodies - but why do I need this?).
So, if our leaders are so kind, why shouldn't they give me what belongs to me rightfully and justly? Somehow I need to use a tailwind ...
I have to think... A difficult problem is in front of me (in front of a simple taxpayer)...
[MMCDXXXIV. Towards the Moon. I pay taxes. A diary note. - October 18, 2021.
MMCDXXXV. Towards the Moon. I'm concerned. I would like to pay the unpaid tax. A diary note. - October 18, 2021.
MMCDXLV. Towards the Moon. By the Front Door. A diary note. - October 22, 2021.
MMCDXLVI. Towards the Moon. While listening to the Valdai Speech. A diary note. - October 23, 2021.
MMCDLXXIII. Towards the Moon. While reading the G20 ROME LEADERS" DECLARATION. A diary note. - November 1, 2021.
MMDXXXIV. Towards the Moon. The recovery in the tax base is approaching. A diary note. - November 26, 2021.
MMDXXXV. Towards the Moon. A non-payment of tax (in full) and a tax secrecy. A diary note. - November 26, 2021.
MMDXLIII. Towards the Moon. The amount of unpaid tax is being specified. A diary note. - November 30, 2021.
MMDCXVI. Towards the Moon. Unpaid (in full) taxes and trips to the taiga. A diary note. - December 24, 2021.
MMDCXVIII. Towards the Moon. Mirrors of replies. A diary note. - December 25, 2021.
MMDCXIX. Toward the Moon. A state official. And an intermediary broker. A diary note. -December 25, 2021.
MMDCXXIV. Toward the Moon. The Ministry of Finance and the tax interests of the state. A diary note. - December 26, 2021.
MMDCXXVII. Toward the Moon. A letter from the Federal Tax Service of the Russian Federation (Moscow). A diary note. - December 27, 2021.
MMDCLXXXVIII. Towards the Moon. The application was sent by affiliation. A diary note. - January 14, 2022.
MMDCCLXII. Towards the Moon. "Conversation of the Mute with the Deaf" (at the Russial Foreign Ministry) or Whether the Rostov Oblast is under the sovereignty of the Russian Federation. A diary note. - February 10, 2022.
MMDCCLXV. Towards the Moon. Reflections before the applying to the Council of Ministers of the Russian Federation. A diary note. - February 11, 2022.
MMDCCLXX. Towards the Moon. The optimal variant of the address to the Council of Ministers of the Russian Federation. A diary note. - February 14, 2022.].
February 15, 2022 12:34
Translation from Russian into English: February 15, 2022 14:50
Владимир Владимирович Залесский "К Луне. Компенсации за прекращение государством моего права собственности. Дневниковая заметка".
{ 2802. К Луне. Компенсации за прекращение государством моего права собственности. Дневниковая заметка.
MMDCCLXXII. Towards the Moon. A compensation for the termination of my property rights by the state. A diary note. }